Thursday 12 November 2009

UK: Scotland: winding-up unregistered companies

Lord Hodge, sitting in the Court of Session (Outer House) has ordered the winding-up, under Section 221 of the Insolvency Act (1986), of eleven companies registered overseas but with their principal place of business in Scotland: see HSBC Bank Plc, Re An Order To Wind Up Kirkbride Investments Ltd [2009] CSOH 147. With regard to the exercise of the court's discretion, Lord Hodge observed that the approach adopted by the English courts was appropriate in Scotland. He stated (para. [11]):

There is no recent Scots case law on this issue but I am satisfied that the approach of the English courts is appropriate and I recall that our courts have adopted that approach in applications which have not resulted in written opinions. In similar circumstances Lord Grieve in Inland Revenue Commissioners v Highland Engineering Limited 1975 SLT 203 relied on English case law in his interpretation of the provisions of the Companies Act 1948 in relation to the winding up of unregistered companies and observed that it was desirable that the courts in each jurisdiction should interpret a United Kingdom statute, such as the Companies Act, in the same way. In Marshall, Petitioner (1895) 22 R 697 the First Division used English authority to inform their interpretation of section 199 of the Companies Act 1862".

No comments: